Montreal Girl Found Dead in New York; Father Charged With Second-Degree Murder in Heartbreaking Cross-Border Case

 

Tragedy Unfolds Across Borders as Police Uncover Death of Missing 13-Year-Old Girl and Arrest Her Father in Connection With the Crime

A heartbreaking cross-border case has shaken both Canada and the United States after the body of a missing 13-year-old girl from Montreal was discovered in a wooded area in Ticonderoga, New York. Her father, who had also been reported missing, is now facing a charge of second-degree murder.

This tragic story has gripped the public in both countries and sparked important conversations about child safety, mental health, and the responsibilities of caregivers in vulnerable family dynamics.

Timeline of Events: A Sudden Disappearance Turns Into a Grim Discovery

The sequence of events began when Montreal police issued a missing persons alert for a 13-year-old girl and her 36-year-old father. The pair had last been seen on July 17, 2025, and were believed to be traveling together in a red SUV.

https://amarsonpost.com/tim-hortons-customers-rally-for-a-cause-on-camp-day-with-generous-donations/

Worries mounted quickly, especially from the girl’s mother, who had previously raised concerns about her daughter’s safety during unsupervised visits with her father. The public alert stated there were reasons to fear for the girl’s well-being, and an AMBER Alert was under consideration.

Just days later, on July 19, New York State Police located the body of the girl in a remote, forested area near Ticonderoga, a small town about 160 km south of Montreal. Her father was found shortly afterward, alive but in distress, and taken into custody.

Authorities confirmed on July 20 that the father was charged with second-degree murder in connection with the death of his daughter.

Who Was the Victim? A Life Cut Tragically Short

The victim, whose name is being withheld at the family’s request, was described by her school and neighbors as a kind, quiet, and creative young girl. She had a love for reading, dancing, and animals. According to reports, she was just weeks away from beginning high school.

Friends of the family revealed that her parents had separated years ago and were engaged in a shared custody arrangement. The girl’s mother had reportedly voiced concerns about the father’s behavior in the past, describing erratic mood swings and controlling tendencies.

https://amarsonpost.com/9-ontario-first-nations-seek-injunction-against-bill-5-citing-clear-and-present-danger-to-indigenous-rights-and-land/

Montreal police had previously been called to mediate custody exchanges between the parents but found no immediate threats at the time.

Legal Proceedings: Second-Degree Murder Charges Laid in U.S. Court

The father, whose identity is being withheld to protect the dignity of the victim, appeared in a New York State court on July 21. He was formally charged with second-degree murder, which in New York implies intentional killing without premeditation.

The charge was based on a combination of forensic evidence, statements made during his arrest, and surveillance footage obtained from both Canada and the U.S. border areas.

The accused has not yet entered a plea. A public defender has been appointed, and he is being held without bail at Essex County Jail in Elizabethtown, NY. He is expected to face extradition issues if further charges are brought in Canada.

https://amarsonpost.com/farmer-protests-controversial-policy-at-danielle-smith-town-hall-sparks-public-outcry-and-media-attention/

Cross-Border Collaboration: A Joint Investigation

This devastating case has highlighted the strong collaboration between Canadian and American authorities. Law enforcement from Montreal, the Sûreté du Québec, the FBI, and the New York State Police worked together closely to track the vehicle using license plate readers, GPS pings, and witness reports.

Once the vehicle was located in New York, the area was cordoned off and searched. It was then that officers made the heartbreaking discovery of the girl’s body. Investigators said they are still gathering more evidence, including digital communications and possible motives.

The FBI has confirmed that the case will remain a state matter unless federal charges are deemed necessary. Both governments have expressed condolences and gratitude for the cross-border cooperation.

Family and Community Reaction: Mourning a Life Lost Too Soon

The girl’s school held a vigil on July 21, where classmates and teachers lit candles and laid flowers in her memory. Many attendees wept openly as a moment of silence was observed.

The mother, speaking through a family spokesperson, said she is “utterly devastated” and thanked law enforcement and the public for their support. “My daughter was my world. She deserved a life full of love and safety, not this,” she said in a short written statement.

https://amarsonpost.com/questions-surround-quadeville-attack-as-residents-voice-frustrations-at-police-town-hall/

Montreal Mayor Valérie Plante also expressed her sorrow, calling the case a “gut-wrenching tragedy that no family should ever have to endure.”

Rising Concerns: Custody Disputes and Child Protection

This tragedy has sparked broader concerns about how custody disputes are handled in Canada and the limitations of current child protection systems. Legal experts say that while family court judges strive to ensure shared parental access, red flags are often difficult to act on unless there is solid evidence of abuse or neglect.

“It’s a painful reality, but sometimes the system doesn’t intervene until it’s too late,” said Me. Caroline Roy, a family law attorney in Montreal. “There are gaps in how we assess risk, particularly in high-conflict custody situations.”

Mental health advocates are also urging the government to provide better psychological evaluations and monitoring for parents undergoing custody battles, especially where emotional instability is evident.

Looking Ahead: Justice, Grief, and Healing

As the legal proceedings continue, the family and community are left to grieve a tremendous loss. Support services have been set up at the girl’s school and local community centers in both Montreal and Ticonderoga.

Many are calling for legislative reviews and improved cooperation between family courts, child protection agencies, and law enforcement to better prevent such tragedies.

While the justice system begins its slow and difficult work, one thing remains painfully clear: a young life was taken far too soon, and a community will never be the same.

If you or someone you know is experiencing a crisis related to domestic violence, mental health, or child custody concerns, help is available. In Canada, call Kids Help Phone at 1-800-668-6868. In the U.S., contact the National Child Abuse Hotline at 1-800-422-4453.